Government land acquisition ruled invalid by Victorian court
The Supreme Court of Victoria has found that the State Government did not properly justify its decision to compulsorily acquire approximately 227 hectares of land at Mount Cottrell, and that the acquisition notice was also invalid. The decision confirms that planning controls identifying land for future acquisition do not make acquisition automatic, because the Government must still show genuine and reasonable grounds when it exercises the power. Landowners whose properties have been earmarked for acquisition, and authorities with compulsory acquisition powers, should review their position and processes in light of the ruling.
On 6 November 2026, the Supreme Court of Victoria handed down its ruling, in which it held that the Government cannot compulsorily acquire private land without properly justifying its decision.
In Mount Cottrell Properties Pty Ltd v Minister for Environment [2026] VSC 721, following a 6-day hearing held in May 2025, the Court found that the State Government did not properly justify its decision to acquire land owned by Macpherson Kelley’s client, Mount Cottrell Properties Pty Ltd, for the proposed Western Grassland Reserves.
The Court ruled that both the decision to acquire the land and the notice issued to the landowner were invalid.
The decision confirms that even where land has been identified for a future public project, the Government must still be able to justify why the land needs to be acquired at the time the decision is made. For many Australians, compulsory acquisition brings to mind The Castle. While this case involved farmland rather than a suburban family home, it shows that when the Government takes private property, it must demonstrate a lawful basis for doing so.
This ruling is relevant to landowners whose properties have been earmarked for future public acquisition, as well as government agencies and other authorities that have the power to compulsorily acquire land.
Key takeaways for landowners and acquiring authorities
The Court confirmed that:
- decision-makers must have genuine and reasonable grounds for acquiring land;
- the Government cannot rely on explanations developed after a decision has been made to justify the acquisition;
- marking land for possible acquisition in planning documents does not make acquisition automatic or inevitable;
- where land is being acquired for environmental or conservation purposes, decision-makers must properly consider the characteristics and condition of the particular land; and
- acquisition notices must accurately explain both why the land is being acquired and why the land is suitable for that purpose.
What led to the Mount Cottrell acquisition?
The case involved approximately 227 hectares of rural land at Mount Cottrell.
The land formed part of the proposed Western Grassland Reserves, a conservation project intended to protect native grasslands affected by Melbourne’s continued urban growth. The area was identified for potential acquisition in planning controls introduced in 2010, and the State had committed to acquiring the reserve land within ten years.
In December 2020, the Minister made decisions to effect the compulsory acquisition of our client’s property.
A formal notice was later issued to the landowner in February 2021, stating that the property was suitable for inclusion in the reserve because of its ecological significance.
What did the Court decide?
- The Government needed more than a general belief that the land should be acquired
The key issue was whether the Minister had reasonable grounds for deciding that the land should be acquired for environmental conservation purposes.
The State argued that the Court should take a limited approach when reviewing the decision. The Court disagreed.
Justice Finanzio held that where legislation requires a decision to be made on “reasonable grounds”, the Court must look closely at what reasons were actually relied upon and whether those reasons would objectively support the decision.
Given that compulsory acquisition interferes with private property rights, the Court said a higher level of scrutiny is required.
- The reasons for the acquisition could not be properly identified
The Minister did not provide reasons explaining why the acquisition was approved. Instead, the State relied on departmental briefing materials and the long planning history of the reserve project. The Court found that this was not enough.
Several reasons identified in the briefing material, such as rising land values, available funding and the landowner’s refusal to sell voluntarily, were found to have little or no relevance to whether the land should be acquired for environmental purposes.
The remaining justification, that the acquisition would help connect other reserve land already acquired, was described as vague and unsupported.
Ultimately, the Court could not clearly identify the basis on which the Minister reached the required level of satisfaction before approving the acquisition.
- Planning controls do not make acquisition inevitable
A significant part of the State’s case was that the land had been earmarked for inclusion in the reserve for many years and was subject to a Public Acquisition Overlay (a planning control that identifies land that a Government or public authority may need to acquire in the future, for a public purpose, such as a road, railway, park, or other infrastructure project). The Court rejected the suggestion that these earlier planning decisions effectively guaranteed that the land would later be acquired.
Justice Finanzio noted that planning controls may identify land that could be acquired in the future, but they do not remove the Government’s obligation to justify acquisition when the power is eventually exercised.
The Court also observed that:
-
- only a relatively small proportion of the reserve area had been acquired by 2020;
- delays had created recognised risks to the environmental objectives of the project;
- parts of the land were outside areas previously identified as most important for conservation; and
- there was limited public information explaining how the final reserve boundaries had been determined.
In those circumstances, the Court found that a reasonable decision-maker should have considered whether all of the land was still needed for the stated environmental purpose.
- The acquisition notice was also invalid
The Court separately found that the notice issued to the landowner was defective.
The notice stated that the land was suitable for acquisition because of “its ecological significance”. However, the State accepted there was no evidence before the Minister demonstrating that the land itself had ecological significance.
Justice Finanzio held that compulsory acquisition laws must be followed strictly. If a notice contains a material error about the purpose of the acquisition or why the land is suitable, that defect cannot simply be overlooked.
What does the decision mean in practice?
This decision reinforces that compulsory acquisition is a significant power and cannot be exercised simply because land has long been identified for a future public project.
For landowners, the judgment confirms that planning controls identifying land for possible acquisition do not automatically guarantee that acquisition will occur. Government decisions must still comply with the law and can be challenged where they do not.
For government agencies and acquiring authorities, the decision is a reminder that they must be able to clearly explain why particular land is needed and ensure that acquisition notices accurately reflect the true reasons for the decision.
The Court’s message is clear: compulsory acquisition powers must be exercised carefully, transparently and in strict accordance with the law.
If your land has been earmarked for future acquisition, or you have received an acquisition notice, please contact Macpherson Kelley’s Melbourne Litigation and Dispute Resolution team for advice.
The information contained in this article is general in nature and cannot be relied on as legal advice nor does it create an engagement. Please contact one of our lawyers listed above for advice about your specific situation.
more
insights
Macpherson Kelley adds leading employment and safety lawyer to Adelaide team as Principal
From farm to boardroom: What Queensland businesses need to know about biosecurity
China’s new trade mark laws: What brand owners need to know
stay up to date with our news & insights
Government land acquisition ruled invalid by Victorian court
The Supreme Court of Victoria has found that the State Government did not properly justify its decision to compulsorily acquire approximately 227 hectares of land at Mount Cottrell, and that the acquisition notice was also invalid. The decision confirms that planning controls identifying land for future acquisition do not make acquisition automatic, because the Government must still show genuine and reasonable grounds when it exercises the power. Landowners whose properties have been earmarked for acquisition, and authorities with compulsory acquisition powers, should review their position and processes in light of the ruling.
On 6 November 2026, the Supreme Court of Victoria handed down its ruling, in which it held that the Government cannot compulsorily acquire private land without properly justifying its decision.
In Mount Cottrell Properties Pty Ltd v Minister for Environment [2026] VSC 721, following a 6-day hearing held in May 2025, the Court found that the State Government did not properly justify its decision to acquire land owned by Macpherson Kelley’s client, Mount Cottrell Properties Pty Ltd, for the proposed Western Grassland Reserves.
The Court ruled that both the decision to acquire the land and the notice issued to the landowner were invalid.
The decision confirms that even where land has been identified for a future public project, the Government must still be able to justify why the land needs to be acquired at the time the decision is made. For many Australians, compulsory acquisition brings to mind The Castle. While this case involved farmland rather than a suburban family home, it shows that when the Government takes private property, it must demonstrate a lawful basis for doing so.
This ruling is relevant to landowners whose properties have been earmarked for future public acquisition, as well as government agencies and other authorities that have the power to compulsorily acquire land.
Key takeaways for landowners and acquiring authorities
The Court confirmed that:
- decision-makers must have genuine and reasonable grounds for acquiring land;
- the Government cannot rely on explanations developed after a decision has been made to justify the acquisition;
- marking land for possible acquisition in planning documents does not make acquisition automatic or inevitable;
- where land is being acquired for environmental or conservation purposes, decision-makers must properly consider the characteristics and condition of the particular land; and
- acquisition notices must accurately explain both why the land is being acquired and why the land is suitable for that purpose.
What led to the Mount Cottrell acquisition?
The case involved approximately 227 hectares of rural land at Mount Cottrell.
The land formed part of the proposed Western Grassland Reserves, a conservation project intended to protect native grasslands affected by Melbourne’s continued urban growth. The area was identified for potential acquisition in planning controls introduced in 2010, and the State had committed to acquiring the reserve land within ten years.
In December 2020, the Minister made decisions to effect the compulsory acquisition of our client’s property.
A formal notice was later issued to the landowner in February 2021, stating that the property was suitable for inclusion in the reserve because of its ecological significance.
What did the Court decide?
- The Government needed more than a general belief that the land should be acquired
The key issue was whether the Minister had reasonable grounds for deciding that the land should be acquired for environmental conservation purposes.
The State argued that the Court should take a limited approach when reviewing the decision. The Court disagreed.
Justice Finanzio held that where legislation requires a decision to be made on “reasonable grounds”, the Court must look closely at what reasons were actually relied upon and whether those reasons would objectively support the decision.
Given that compulsory acquisition interferes with private property rights, the Court said a higher level of scrutiny is required.
- The reasons for the acquisition could not be properly identified
The Minister did not provide reasons explaining why the acquisition was approved. Instead, the State relied on departmental briefing materials and the long planning history of the reserve project. The Court found that this was not enough.
Several reasons identified in the briefing material, such as rising land values, available funding and the landowner’s refusal to sell voluntarily, were found to have little or no relevance to whether the land should be acquired for environmental purposes.
The remaining justification, that the acquisition would help connect other reserve land already acquired, was described as vague and unsupported.
Ultimately, the Court could not clearly identify the basis on which the Minister reached the required level of satisfaction before approving the acquisition.
- Planning controls do not make acquisition inevitable
A significant part of the State’s case was that the land had been earmarked for inclusion in the reserve for many years and was subject to a Public Acquisition Overlay (a planning control that identifies land that a Government or public authority may need to acquire in the future, for a public purpose, such as a road, railway, park, or other infrastructure project). The Court rejected the suggestion that these earlier planning decisions effectively guaranteed that the land would later be acquired.
Justice Finanzio noted that planning controls may identify land that could be acquired in the future, but they do not remove the Government’s obligation to justify acquisition when the power is eventually exercised.
The Court also observed that:
-
- only a relatively small proportion of the reserve area had been acquired by 2020;
- delays had created recognised risks to the environmental objectives of the project;
- parts of the land were outside areas previously identified as most important for conservation; and
- there was limited public information explaining how the final reserve boundaries had been determined.
In those circumstances, the Court found that a reasonable decision-maker should have considered whether all of the land was still needed for the stated environmental purpose.
- The acquisition notice was also invalid
The Court separately found that the notice issued to the landowner was defective.
The notice stated that the land was suitable for acquisition because of “its ecological significance”. However, the State accepted there was no evidence before the Minister demonstrating that the land itself had ecological significance.
Justice Finanzio held that compulsory acquisition laws must be followed strictly. If a notice contains a material error about the purpose of the acquisition or why the land is suitable, that defect cannot simply be overlooked.
What does the decision mean in practice?
This decision reinforces that compulsory acquisition is a significant power and cannot be exercised simply because land has long been identified for a future public project.
For landowners, the judgment confirms that planning controls identifying land for possible acquisition do not automatically guarantee that acquisition will occur. Government decisions must still comply with the law and can be challenged where they do not.
For government agencies and acquiring authorities, the decision is a reminder that they must be able to clearly explain why particular land is needed and ensure that acquisition notices accurately reflect the true reasons for the decision.
The Court’s message is clear: compulsory acquisition powers must be exercised carefully, transparently and in strict accordance with the law.
If your land has been earmarked for future acquisition, or you have received an acquisition notice, please contact Macpherson Kelley’s Melbourne Litigation and Dispute Resolution team for advice.